|
Hey it's an interesting theory but I think it's based on some incorrect assertions.
It's important to remember that serotonin is still not fully understood in its functioning - and its connection to depression is also not fully understood, nor is it fully proven. Plenty of people don't get relief from SSRIs - which suggests that their depression/anxiety is not solely or perhaps even partly related to serotonin issues.
That said, from my understanding, serotonin is actually produced by daily activities such as exercise. I think you would be hard-pressed to find on here someone who regularly felt better from doing nothing - and there are plenty here who spend all day in bed and just get more and more miserable.
It's also not correct, I believe, to say that the body uses serotonin more quickly when it is stressed. It actually gets released, for instance, when you bleed, or when you eat something which irritates your system.
It's not at all clear that serotonin is replenished during sleep - at least one source I found suggests the opposite. From some internet research (not always the most reliable!):
"In "The Secrets of Serotonin," Carol Hart suggests that serotonin has a close relationship to the body's sleep-wake cycle. Serotonin levels are highest in the brain stem when you are awake and active, and almost completely absent when we enter REM sleep, the deepest stage of sleep. During sleep, the body's level of melatonin rises sharply. The production of melatonin is dependent on its synthesis in the pineal gland, which is powered by serotonin. While light increases the production of serotonin, darkness spurs on the synthesis of melatonin. Paired together, these two neurotransmitters are key in maintaining the sleep cycle."
It's also important to remember that, as I understand it, SSRIs don't directly increase serotonin production - they stop the serotonin which has already been produced from being re-absorbed - that's why they're called "re-uptake inhibitors".
There actually was an amazing study I read once which suggested that depressed people who were kept awake for extended periods of time actually improved in mood - as compared to people who went to sleep. But that's not really a practical solution....
I am happy to be corrected if I got my facts or information wrong....
This post has been edited by americandownunder: Oct 31 2009, 04:42 AM
--------------------
Midway on our life's journey, I found myself in dark woods, the right road lost. To speak about those woods is hard, so tangled and rough and savage that thinking about it now I feel the old fear stirring. Death is hardly more bitter.
-Dante
|